Off the Bitten Path; Discovering the best burgers at local spots featuring Shake Shop in Cherryville
As part of our "Off the Bitten Path" series, we explore hidden culinary treasures across Gaston County, spotlighting local dining spots steeped in history, tradition, and beloved family recipes. Locals cherish these gems, and we are now sharing them with visitors to enhance your experience. Today, we feature the Shake Shop in Cherryville, where history and flavor collide most deliciously.
Shake Shop in Cherryville
When you first drive by, it won't seem like much, but don't let it fool you! Located just outside the historic downtown of Cherryville on Hwy 150, a busy two-lane road connecting Lincolnton to Shelby, the Shake Shop might appear out of business if you pass by between 2 pm and 4 pm, but come 4 o'clock; this place is hopping!
This old carhop-style establishment, with a low-hung rusty awning, hides the deliciousness created inside. Today, the original service bays serve as parking spots. The locals know the drill: call ahead to beat the rush and pay at the window, just as they did back in the day when mill workers flocked here during shift changes.
The Shake Shop has been a staple in Cherryville since its beginnings in the 1940s, originally owned by the Peeler family. Though it no longer serves ice cream, the restaurant retains its nostalgic charm, evident in the faded Pepsi street sign bearing its original name. The shop's enduring appeal lies in its history and the unwavering quality of its food.
A Taste of Tradition
As you approach the Shake Shop, the aroma of freshly grilled food greets you. Make sure you come prepared. Shake Shop is cash-only! The menu boasts a variety of hearty options, including the famed Lotta burger, Lotta burger with cheese, Lotta Fish, Lotta BBQ, and even a Lotta Grilled Cheese.
Many believe that the Lotta burger, a local legend, originated here. This iconic burger features two loosely packed quarter-pound fresh beef patties on a soft hoagie roll, topped with homemade slaw, tomato, and pickles, then cut in half, often paired with crispy onion rings and the shop's famous jumbo sauce or french fries. It's a culinary delight that locals love and visitors are soon to crave.
A Legacy of Family and Community
The Shake Shop has been in the Jarrett family's care since 1966 when George, better known as "Duck," took over. Today, George's son, Kyle, and his wife, Susan, run it and continue the family tradition. The sense of family extends to the employees, with one dedicated worker having been with the shop for over 20 years, and the Jarretts remain devoted to maintaining the shop's original hours to serve the community. The restaurant's history and the family's perseverance have made it a cherished part of Cherryville's identity.
A Must-Visit Destination
We highly recommend you seek out this off-the-beaten-path restaurant. After enjoying a Lotta burger, make time for a stroll through downtown historic Cherryville, recently revitalized to recapture its vibrant past. Several murals paint stories of Cherryville's past, including the Heritage Mural, which depicts the tradition of shooting muskets on New Year's Eve. One can also find unique gift shops and boutiques worth exploring. For a deeper dive into the region's history, try the C Grier Beam Truck Museum, which tells the history of Carolina Freight Company, or head over to the Gaston County Museum in nearby Dallas, NC, for a look at their exhibit on the local textile industry.
Best burger off the beaten path
Shake Shop
Open Tuesday through Friday, 11 am - 2 pm and 4 pm - 8 pm
505 W Church Street, Cherryville, NC 28021
Shake Shop is a Cash Only Establishment
Discover More "Off the Bitten Path"
As we continue our "Off the Bitten Path" series, we'll uncover more of Gaston County's best-kept secrets. Stay tuned as we explore Blackwoods in Kings Mountain, Byrum's in Belmont, Kyle Fletcher's, RO's, Black's BBQ in Gastonia, Dan's, Edgewood Grill, and Whiskey Mill in Bessemer City. These local favorites, each with a unique story and flavor, are essential stops for anyone looking to experience the true essence of Gaston County.
Off the Bitten Path story and interview by Jennifer Easler, of Gaston County Tourism Directed/Edited by Melissa McCauley
